PHP RFC: Persistent curl share handle improvement

• Version: 1.1
• Date: 2024-11-27
• Author: Eric Norris, erictnorris@gmail.com
• Status: Under Discussion
• First Published at: https://wiki.php.net/rfc/curl_share_persistence

The vote for PHP RFC: Add persistent curl share handles passed, but discussion raised after voting brought up the possibility of an improved implementation.

After finishing up the original implementation pull request, I had some free time to explore an alternative implementation: https://github.com/php/php-src/pull/16937.

As a reminder, the previously accepted signature was: curl_share_init(?array $share_options, ?string $persistent_id): CurlShareHandle.

Tim Düsterhus noted concerns about allowing the CURL_LOCK_DATA_COOKIE share option:

Accidentally sharing a cookie jar for unrelated requests due to a badly chosen `$persistent_id` sounds like a vulnerability to is bound to happen to someone.

This was addressed with an update to the wording of the RFC, but still remains a valid option.

Tim Düsterhus also noted concerns about chosen $persistent_id arguments:

Also badly chosen $persistent_ids might result in a large number of handles accumulating, without any kind of garbage collection. For the existing persistent handles (e.g. for database connections), the ID is chosen by PHP itself, ensuring a somewhat predictable behavior.

This was not addressed in the RFC.

The implementation pull request stated:

It is noteworthy that calling curl_share_setopt on the persistent handle would affect future requests using the handle; we could consider preventing this.

This did not come up in any discussion on the mailing list. While it is possible to prevent this with a runtime check in curl_share_setopt, and that may be within the bounds of the RFC implementation, it is not preventable via static analysis. The type signature of curl_share_setopt will not warn a user if they are passing in a persistent CurlShareHandle.

Introduce a new curl_share_init_persistent(array $share_options) function instead of adding optional parameters to the curl_share_init function.

The new function will return a CurlSharePersistentHandle object that is usable with curl_setopt via the CURLOPT_SHARE option. The object will not be usable with any existing curl_share_* functions, as it should not be possible to change the options of a CurlSharePersistentHandle once created.

CURL_LOCK_DATA_COOKIE will not be allowed as a share option.

The documentation for this function may look like:

curl_share_init_persistent — Initialize a persistent cURL share handle.

curl_share_init_persistent(array $share_options): CurlSharePersistentHandle

Initialize a persistent cURL share handle with the given share options. It will not be destroyed at the end of the PHP request. If a persistent share handle with the same set of $share_options is found, it will be reused.

• $share_options — an array of CURL_LOCK_DATA_* constants. Note: CURL_LOCK_DATA_COOKIE is not allowed and, if specified, this function will throw a RuntimeException. Sharing cookies between PHP requests may lead to inadvertently mixing up sensitive cookies between users.

Returns a persistent cURL handle on success.

• CURL_LOCK_DATA_COOKIE is not allowed, which, roughly speaking, keeps curl share handles stateless. This avoids a large class of potentially hard-to-debug errors.
• Users no longer have to choose a persistent ID; the function implementation will reuse a single curl share handle per unique set of $share_options. This simplifies usage:
  • Users can start using new share options immediately without needing to remember to also change the $persistent_id.
  • Users cannot accidentally use a $persistent_id that corresponds to a handle with $share_options different from what they would expect.
  • Users cannot accidentally balloon memory usage via a poorly chosen dynamic $persistent_id.
• Since CurlSharePersistentHandle is a unique type, it is not usable with any existing curl_share_* functions. This means that once created, a CurlSharePersistentHandle is immutable.

None. the previous RFC implementation has not landed in any released PHP version.

Next PHP minor release.

Effectively none. SAPIs will consume more memory proportional to the number of persistent curl share handles, but the number of unique possibilities for $share_options is too low to matter.

ext/curl will have a new function.

None.

None.

None.

This vote requires a ⅔ majority:

Accept curl_share_init_persistent(array $share_options): CurlSharePersistentHandle over the previous RFC signature
Real name	Yes	No
ashnazg (ashnazg)
derick (derick)
galvao (galvao)
girgias (girgias)
kalle (kalle)
petk (petk)
sergey (sergey)
theodorejb (theodorejb)
timwolla (timwolla)
Count:	9	0

This vote requires a simple majority:

Disallow CURL_LOCK_DATA_COOKIE in $share_options
Real name	Yes	No
ashnazg (ashnazg)
derick (derick)
galvao (galvao)
girgias (girgias)
kalle (kalle)
petk (petk)
sergey (sergey)
theodorejb (theodorejb)
timwolla (timwolla)
Count:	9	0

• https://github.com/php/php-src/pull/16937

• https://wiki.php.net/rfc/curl_share_persistence
• https://externals.io/message/125858

• Initially, it will not be possible to pass a CurlSharePersistentHandle to curl_share_close. Calling curl_share_close is currently a NOP for CurlShareHandle objects, meaning that code does not have to consider handling a closed (invalid) CurlShareHandle object. In keeping with the spirit of making invalid states unrepresentable, we should not allow users to close CurlSharePersistentHandle. If a valid use-case comes up in the future, we could revisit this.